Who is right, the sidereal astrologers or tropical astrologers?
These are just two different ways of viewing the same thing in my view. The relative positions of the astronomical bodies really do not change and the Zodiacs can carry meaning for the observer. Astrology is not a hard science and offers many ways to understanding. The key is how the astrologer serves and is able to bring to the client the awareness necessary to aid in their fulfillment and growth. Soon we will require a galactic astrology and that will change the view of astrology completely. Heliocentric astrology is also a valid application of astrology and offers us insight in yet another way.