Which storyline was worst, Mae Youngs hand birth or Katie Vick?
I’m not going to bother with your additional details part, as everyone Trolls at one point or another. Anyway… I’m glad you picked the two worst storylines of the Attitude Era. People keep forgetting that there was a lot of crap that came about during that time as well. The only reason we loved it so much was that there was competition that made sense… so both shows had to put on interesting shows that pulled fans from the other show. And a lot remember it so fondly, because they were kids during that time, and nostalgia has a way of making something that was mediocre into a full-out ball of awesomeness. Now to answer your question… In my opinion Katie Vick was worse. The reasoning is that although the Hand was stupid, and pointless… it was the END of a silly storyline that no one cared about. Katie Vick on the other hand was supposed to be the BEGINNING of a story that involved not the low-card talent of Mark Henry, but the main event talent of Triple H and Kane… and the new
