Where is the Best Pizza in Buffalo, New York?
As the owner of My Tomato Pie, I would like to thank all my customers who have supported us over the last nine years. It is you that have made us one of Buffalo?s #1 Independently Owned Restaurants. Without you, our excellent homemade food would only be enjoyed by friends and family who have kept these recipes secret for generations and generations.I have been lucky enough to prepare many very special meals for you and your families. As many of my family recipes? have been used for your special meals in the restaurant, our banquet rooms, or possibly catered right at your house.As I continue to serve your family, your friends, and you, please show your support by giving us feedback. Let me know if you ever want me to run a special that you might be craving, or even tell me if we could have been a little better.Our menu has developed through the years because of your feedback, so please keep it coming. Thanks,AnthonyPros + Great Food, Great People.Cons – None.
i grew up with PJ Pizza as a treat and have always told others about PJ. in 2007 my Mom became terminally ill and while caring for her I flew my aunt in from out of state to see her for the last time. meanwhile it was late at night (closing time) when i called in an order for 2 sheets Pizza with cheese, mushroom and sausage to feed our family while my wife drove to the airport to pick up my Aunt. the staff on duty were very friendly despite my LATE order not even knowing the circumstances. when I returned with the Pizza Mom could smell it and asked for some. as I fed Mom the pizza all she said was MMMM you sure know how to order a Pizza. it was the most she ate in a long time and it was her last meal before she passed. i just want the staff of PJ August 20th 2007 to know what a fantastic job they did and that Mom enjoyed her last dinner prepared by them. all i can say is Thank You to the staff of PJ on August 20th 2007
if you want a good pizza imperial is where you should go. no where in Buffalo will you find a better deal for a family dinner . The pizza’s are huge and the the subs are loaded. The wings are great and always cooked to perfection. I have never had a bad meal at Imperial. They also have dinners and great Fish frys.Trust me once you’ve tried Imperial you will be a repeat customer. I live in Amherst and its worth the drive.Pros + GREAT FOOD AND GOOD SERVICECons – none!!!!!!
I remember several outstanding NY style pizza places here in the 1960s – gone now. When I returned after living in New York and New Jersey I was stunned by just how bad the local pizza was. Thick, doughy, chewy like catsup on thick bread. But then I found Gino & Joes. One of only 2 real NY Style pizzerias in the city (the other is Zetti’s) if you like thin crust, great sauce, large slice pizza this is the place to go! Just wish they had more stores and were open on weekends and nights.Pros + Inexpensive, Great PizzaCons – Closed nights
