Where does an applicant respond to the comments of the reviewers?
A. The applicant should acknowledge the reviewer’s concerns and issues in the Introduction section (limited to three pages, see Form 424 instructions), and explain how the revised application is different from the previous application. Changes to the application in response to the critiques should be highlighted by change in font or indentation as outlined in the instructions. The concerns and issues are noted in the Resume and Summary of Discussion section and/or under each reviewer’s critique of the summary statement. If the applicant does not agree with a reviewer’s comments, the rationale for disagreeing with the reviewer should be explained.
Related Questions
- Did the GEO-4 report undergo a peer review process? How were comments from reviewers addressed in the drafting of the GEO-4?
- Can a member of the public contact the commission or an individual member to offer comments about an applicant?
- Where does an applicant respond to the comments of the reviewers?
Where does an applicant respond to the comments of the reviewers?