Whats the difference between an editor and a book doctor?
In general terms, an editor usually works for the publisher; a book doctor always works for the author. When I edit manuscripts for publishing houses, I correct all errors in grammar, punctuation, syntax, and noncompliance with Chicago Style, and the author rarely gets the opportunity to accept, reject, or even know why I made those changes. When I work as a book doctor for authors, though, authors maintain complete control over the manuscript, with the right to accept or reject any suggestion without having to give me any explanation. In addition, with hard-copy editing and hybrid editing, authors get concept editing and an evaluation that covers every element, including organization, characterization, plot, pacing, dialogue, creative writing, marketability, and many other details. The section on grammar, punctuation, and syntax explains why each mark was made on the manuscript, so authors learn a great deal in the process.
