What is meant by academic judgement and why am I not permitted to question it?
The University operates on the assumption that the Examiners know more about the subject of study than the students and that they are experienced in determining the level of attainment. You may not therefore base an appeal on your belief that your work was worthy of a higher grade than the one awarded. If you obtain the report of the examiners or a marked script through a subject access request, you may not question the points awarded unless there is evidence of a miscalculation when the score was aggregated.
