What is expected for discussion of classmates papers?
Comment on at least five papers by posting in the Discussion section, and by engaging in oral discussion. In your comments, you may ask questions of the author, confirm, comment on or argue with the conclusions, indicate strengths or weaknesses, common issues which both you and the other author wrote about, larger issues which need to be discussed, and so forth. Assess the work of the group as a whole: what issues seem to be common, or unique; as a group did the papers enlighten? Did issues you raised as a peer reviewer get addressed? Are there issues suggested by the paper suitable for further research? Your course may be set up in such a way that the Moderators of a session have special responsibilities to make sure this happens. Check the comments on your own paper in the discussion section, and respond to questions and comments posted by your fellow students or by the instructor. 9. What is the final assessment exercise? For RELI2040-01 FALL 2009: Assess about five papers (you can
