What is a Quality Circle Review?
A quality circle review is a process similar to the one used by reviewers of research grant proposals and in some respects resembles the dissertation committee. These review circles are often comprised of specialists – individuals internal to your field of expertise, and generalists – individuals external to your field of expertise. As readers of your dissertation or research grant proposal, both groups have distinct advantages and serve the writer by offering opportunities to clarify and strengthen the writing and to ensure that the linguistic frame of the document rests in accord with the conceptual plan of development. Specialists in your field of expertise are already familiar with the language and current scholarly conversations relevant to your particular discipline, and so they read your work with an accepted understanding of the terms, practices or issues. However, when writing for the generalist population, you, as writer, will have to step outside of your field of expertise a
