What does the appellee do at oral argument?
Remember that it is the appellant’s job to convince the Supreme Court that the Superior Court judge made a mistake. It is the appellee’s job to convince the Supreme Court that the Superior Court’s decision was correct so that the court upholds that decision. Before the argument, write notes or an outline of why you think that the Superior Court decision was correct. During the argument, listen carefully to what the appellant says in her opening argument. Write down notes about any issues you want to address when it is your turn to argue. Clearly and concisely tell the court why you think the appellant is wrong and the Superior Court decision below is correct. The appellee does not get time for a rebuttal argument so make sure you say everything you think is important during your allotted time.
