What are the chances of getting pregnant on the sugar pill?
This isn’t “common” for those with a consistent pill schedule, but it is one of the main causes of pill failure, other than user error. If the pill is taken properly, it is effective 99.5% of the time, so the possibility of pill failure for this reason is very slim. This is much more likely to have been caused by an inconsistent pill schedule, which makes the pill much less effective. Also, unless her ovulation schedule was abnormal, she didn’t get pregnant while on the sugar pill, but most likely because she delayed starting a new packet of birth control for an extra day or so after the sugar pill, making it possible for her to ovulate and conceive while on her pills.