What Are American Idol Girls Are Made Of?
I thought Paige was decent but her nerves got in the way. Simon thinks she had the best voice out of all the girls but thought her song choice was too “wedding singer.” Kara disagrees and says the song was a perfect choice to show off the soul in her voice. Randy says she did a great job. Ellen related to her nerves and liked her singing. Ashley Rodriguez sang Leona Lewis’ Happy. I thought Ashley sounded really choppy. None of the judges thought it was great and Simon thought she was going to be in trouble after tonight. Janell Wheeler sang Heart’s What About Love. Ashley had some dry moments but she sang with a lot of passion. The judges felt that the song was way too big for her, but they think she’s safe and so do I. Lilly Scott sang The Beatles’ Fixing A Hole. Lilly brought a refreshing folk vibe to the song. Ellen said she had a distinguished voice. Simon now believes that Lilly has the best voice though he’s not feeling any star power from her. Katelyn Epperly performs another Be
