Was it fair to chuck out josiah lemming out of american idol?
Yes it was fair. It’s a competition show with the judges’ opinion as the final say for who goes into the top 24. It’s up to everyone else once those 24 are decided. There were a lot of talented people who were “rejected” as you say Josiah was. Do you think it’s fair that they did not make it either? Just because he has a sob story and is good looking does not give him a special right to make it to the final 24. I’m sorry but it’s really getting old all the talk about Josiah and how talented he was, what a hard life he has, and so on. There has to be ten or twenty other hard stories for his that were not focused on during Hollywood week – he just got the focus I think because he was good looking. I keep on bringing up the young woman from Chicago with the disabled child. She was very talented too. Was it fair for her to be rejected too? It’s a competition show and that’s how things go. Sometimes your fave will make it, sometimes they won’t. Josiah is young enough that he can try again n
