Should third party researchers have access to a forensic DNA database for research purposes?
We consider that it would be inappropriate for third party researchers to have a blanket access to a forensic DNA database for research purposes. In principle, if individuals consented to their DNA profile/bodily sample being used for medical purposes at the time of giving the sample, then this would be acceptable, in the context of the points made at 7.2 and 5.2 above. However, the ability to distinguish between samples on a DNA database given with consent for research and those that have not is likely to be difficult. An additional complication is that certain samples can be taken without the consent of the individual anyway, and it is difficult to see how if taken in these circumstances it would be appropriate for the police to discuss consent for medical research. 10.6 The HGC will be monitoring the area of forensic DNA databases in the future. Are there any other particular issues you would like to draw to the Commission’s attention? We have nothing further to add.
