Is There A Difference Between German-Style and American-Style Tubas?
Much has been said about the differences between a German and American tuba. One commentator wondered if most of the discussion was pedantic B.S. rather than substantive observation, and the point is a good one. The best description I’ve seen of the difference is that the German rotary tubas make a column of sound, more about focus than foundation. But that’s not to say that a good player can’t get more foundation on a German horn than a mediocre player gets from an American horn. I’ve listened to superb players on both types of instrument, though, and the difference in sound is substantial. One well-known orchestral player has played both an Alexander (German) and a Hirsbrunner Grand Orchestral, which is a copy of that ultimate American horn, the large York now owned by the Chicago Symphony. I thought his sound on the Alex was commanding and demanded respect. In contrast to that authoritative sound, the Hirsbrunner, with the same player, produces a warm, sweet-sounding tone, massive w
