Is the taking of a sample by buccal swab an intimate or non-intimate forensic procedure?
20. The Committee is evenly divided on the issue as to whether the taking of a sample by buccal swab, is an “intimate forensic procedure” or a “non-intimate forensic procedure” and is unable to make a recommendation to the House. Whilst some members consider that the taking of a sample by buccal swab, may be “invasive” or “intrusive”, they do not consider that it is intimate. Other members consider that it is an intimate procedure that requires more stringent checks and balances. The Committee is of the view that the matter is essentially one of policy and is an issue that is best determined by the House. (Paragraphs 8.8 – 8.28) What safeguards should attach to certain forensic procedures? 21. The Committee is of the view that certain forensic procedures should be carried out by a person or persons of the same sex as the person being subjected to the forensic procedure. (For a discussion of the position in other jurisdictions studied by the Committee refer to Chapter 5 and 6.) 22. The
