Is Sui Generis a Stronger Bet Than Copyright?
Hasan A. Deveci1 1 MA, LLM, Dip.in Intellectual Property, GCert.Ed., Barrister Formerly lecturer at South Bank University Originality as a requirement of copyright has attracted diverse interpretations both within and across legal systems. Why? Because, it seems, the courts have had to reconcile creativity favoured in civil law countries and industrious labour upheld in common law countries. By allowing for both alternatives the Database Directive (EC) injected a sense of commercial realism. The danger, however, is that the new sui generis right might monopolise information beyond the term granted to copyright. This assertion is explored in four stages. Part I examines originality as a requirement of copyright. Part II considers changes in judicial attitudes in the US and the impact of Feist in common law countries. Part III focuses on the Directive. Part IV engages in comparative analysis of originality and investment as requirements for copyright and database rights respectively. Par
