I decided I need a religion and have picked AMISH. How do I become Amish if I don know any Amish?
I think you should talk with your pregnant Amish girlfriend and ask her about it. She’ll know more than all the English that are on Y/A. If you want, you can chat it over with her father when you discuss the future of his grandchild. Obviously you live near enough to the Amish to meet some and ask questions. Only they really understand it.