How can I become an Israeli citizen?
You shouldn’t have much problem becoming an Israeli citizen. However, you may have some serious issues being recognized as “Jewish” for status purposes by the State and religious authorities within the State, and that is something serious to consider. You may not be able to marry a Jewish woman in Israel unless you convert to Judaism according to Orthodox traditions. I’d contact IRAC (IRAC), which is the Israeli political arm of the Reform Movement, just to get an idea of what else it entails. They probably can tell you a lot more than any of us, but being Jewish for citizenship, but not status, purposes in Israel is sort of a clusterf**k.