Doesn having the Invid return to Earth after the TV series ends sorta contradict the show? Have you read Peter Walkers essay on the subject?
Yes, I have read Peter’s essay on the unlikelihood of the Invid returning, and while I agree with most of it in a sense the damage has already been done. Like I said above, TIW is a sequel to the Robotech RPG, therefore I try to stay fairly consistent with events described in the RPG, including the questionable second invasion by the Invid of Earth. In fact, the primary purpose of TIW is to try and continue what Palladium started, for better or worse. Some people insist that any sequel to Robotech must be 100% consistent with the TV show above all else, or it really isn’t a sequel to Robotech at all. Personally I think these people need to chill out a little. ^_^ I freely admit that TIW is not and never will be completely consistent with the Robotech TV series. However, I’m not going to loose much sleep over that. I hope that people will judge TIW based on how creative and entertaining it is, and not on trivialities and canonical nit-picking.
Related Questions
- Doesn having the Invid return to Earth after the TV series ends sorta contradict the show? Have you read Peter Walkers essay on the subject?
- The series and movie have lame endings! If Hitomi loves Van, why does she leave him behind and return to Earth?
- Is earth the movie version of the Planet Earth TV series?
