Does a researcher retain credit for past accomplishments if they are involved in significant redirection?
As the RGEG states: “A researcher in one field may move into a related field. Such a move does not change Factor 4 credit if the researcher will perform research work in the new field at substantially the same level of competence as before after a reasonably short period.” Within ARS, panels exercise management’s classification authority in applying the RGEG. RPES panels are composed of experienced researchers, who realize that they themselves may sometime face the challenge of redirection (if they haven’t already!). This reality operates to ensure a predictable degree of humanity and common sense when panels make evaluation judgments in redirection situations. It is also important to realize that panels primarily assess the impact of a scientist’s contributions, and the stature and recognition arising therefrom. Panels are not permitted to credit potential or “but for” situations involving substantial redirection, any more than they can in reviewing positions not so impacted.
