Did they keep all the old DeFeo furniture?
Yes, the Lutzes bought most of the DeFeo’s furniture. They did so because it was very good – they liked it better than their old furniture – and it was offered at a price the Lutzes felt they couldn’t refuse. Looking back on it, this may sound strange; but remember the Lutzes were skeptical of the paranormal at the time. George considered himself a “realist”; they didn’t think the house was haunted; and no strange events had taken place yet. It wasn’t like the furniture was soaked in blood or anything. Obviously the mattresses were ruined and were taken out of the house prior to it being on the market. George & Kathy kept their own old bed, as did the children. Apparently they bought the old bedframe that once belonged to Dawn, and moved it to Missy’s room.
