Am I justified in being a tiny bit skeptical?
I can understand the fears you have. All I can say is keep the communication open and hope for the best. My husband and I went through a similar experience, except it was him feeling rejected. That was 2 years ago. We went through the honeymoon phase of sex every morning and night for about 6-7 months, then we sort of settled down a bit, but not back to the way it was. I will never let that happen again. I know I have a good man, and a good marriage. He will never feel rejection from me. No, we don’t have sex twice a day every day, but it’s still pretty frequent (4-5 times a week) and the intimacy isn’t just in the bedroom. We became friends again. Relax some and enjoy the new spark.