A 4-H member used the computer to enhance photographs that she did not take, but pictures that family members have taken. Can this be exhibited in photography since she did not take the pictures?
A. If the 4-H member did not take the photos, we first rule out entries in class 851A or 851B. These two classes are appropriate only if the member took the photos, either with a conventional (film) camera, or with a digital camera. From there, we consider the goals of the member – project and exhibit. If the goal is to create an altered photo or demonstrate a photographic technique (photo enhancement would fit), then class 851C – Contemporary/Creative Photography or 851D – Photography Idea could be appropriate. Read carefully the description for 851C. An exhibit in this class would use photography or photo manipulation techniques and tools to create an image markedly different from the original. The question did not state how extensively the member altered or enhanced the photos. If they enhanced the photos to lighten, darken, remove red eye, add a tree to the background, etc., class 851D is probably a better choice – depending on the goals. The member will need to very clearly state
